by Benn Ray
So here we are after an historic election that saw a wave of Democrats wash in to office. That's a lot of new people for the media to get to know - a lot of Democrats to talk to. You'd think the Sunday news talk shows would be lousy with Democrats, right?
Think gain.
First, some background. According to
a study by Media Matters:
On Sunday political talk shows from 2001-2005:
conservative guests appeared 55% of the time
progressives guests appeared 42% of the timeThe rationale I heard from defenders of the conservative mainstream media was that guest bookings should reflect the party in power. At this point, Democrats will have a comfortable majority in the House and Senate, and the American people turned out in historic numbers to overwhelming elect Barack Obama as president.
In fact, the percentages we should expect the Sunday news talk shows to reflect should be in the ballpark of:
House of Representatives
58% Democrat
40% Republican
5 seats still contested
The Senate
57% Democrat
40% Republican
3 seats still contested
Electoral votes in the presidential election
68% Obama (Democrat)
30% McCain (Republican)
Popular votes in the presidential election
53% Obama (Democrat)
46% McCain (Republican)
So does that mean we can expect to see the Sunday political talk show numbers reverse - and show more of a favoritism toward progressive guests?
An average of the election results would suggest that a fair expectation would be that the Sunday news talk shows (who often frame either how we look at the previous week's news or set the agenda for the following week's news) would now book:
59% progressive guests
39% conservative guests
Don't bet on it.
Today's lineup looks like this:
7 Appearances by Republican current elected officeholders
3 Appearances by Democratic current elected officeholders.
2 Appearances by Republican former elected officeholders.
1 Appearance by a Bush Cabinet Secretary.
T. Boone Pickens
Ted Turner.
73% of today's guests being conservative (I counted T. Boone Pickens - who is a big Republican donor as conservative).
27% of today's guests ranked as progressive (I ranked Ted Turner in with the progressives).
Hm. So what's their excuse now?
Oh right, conservatives do have an awful lot of talking points to force down out throats:
1. America is a center-right nation (it's actually a center-left nation).
2. Obama did not win a mandate from the people (he did win a big mandate).
3. Obama was elected as a centrist (they called him a socialist during the election, so also not true).
4. The reason John McCain lost was because he wasn't a true conservative (while McCain may have had a history of being a "maverick" he actually ran as a true conservative, and so did his running mate Palin).
5. The reason we're in the mess we're in now is because Bush didn't govern as a true conservative (actually he did, he governed as a conservative ideologue).
That is an awful lot of reality that needs to be "corrected", so it only makes sense that the gatekeepers of the public airways give conservatives a disproportionate amount of access to it.
Hm. Maybe it is time we revisit the Fairness Doctrine.
Source.